Bridging the Comprehension Gap: Applying Behavioral Science to Insurance Compliance
Weekly snippets from the Insurance Compliance Insight (ICI) Newsletter. A weekly subscription service published by an insurance compliance professional for insurance compliance professionals!
The insurance industry is abuzz with excitement over a groundbreaking study that could revolutionize how we approach compliance programs, particularly in the realm of annuity suitability. The September 30, 2024 edition of Insurance Compliance Insight features an insightful analysis of the study "Searching for Simplicity: Using Behavioral Science to make Life Insurance Product Information Simple and Effective," published by the Society of Actuaries (SOA) Research Institute in collaboration with Reinsurance Group of America, Inc. (RGA).
While the study primarily focuses on improving consumer comprehension during online life insurance sales, its findings offer a treasure trove of applications for strengthening insurance compliance programs. The article in Insurance Compliance Insight draws a compelling parallel between consumers in the study and producers in compliance contexts, suggesting innovative ways to enhance annuity suitability programs.
The SOA study, conducted by Masters and PhD level scientists from the Global Association of Applied Behavioral Scientists, involved two experiments with approximately 2,000 U.S. residents each. The first experiment aimed to improve comprehension of written messages in the sales process, while the second tested the impact of human- and AI-generated videos on understanding.
Key findings from the study include:
1. Simplification alone is not enough: Merely simplifying complex terminology did not significantly improve comprehension. Instead, combining simple language with other behavioral science techniques yielded the best results.
2. Salience matters: Using techniques like FAQs, icons, and attractive text improved overall comprehension by 21%, with a 40% increase when focusing solely on information presented using these methods.
3. Positive friction enhances understanding: Contrary to conventional wisdom, adding "positive friction" - encouraging deeper engagement with key information - improved overall comprehension by 28%, rising to 59% for specific interactive content.
4. Video content boosts comprehension: Including video alongside other behavioral science techniques increased understanding by an additional 15%.
The Insurance Compliance Insight article suggests two primary areas where these findings can strengthen annuity suitability programs:
1. Product Explanation: Producers, like consumers in the study, must comprehend and explain complex products. Applying the study's techniques to suitability materials and training can enhance producers' ability to understand and communicate product details accurately.
2. Training Effectiveness: The insights on improving consumer understanding can directly enhance producer training, a crucial element of any suitability program.
The article proposes viewing producers as "consumers" of compliance information, applying the same behavioral science principles used to improve customer comprehension to enhance producer understanding and compliance.
Practical strategies for implementing these insights in compliance programs include:
1. Redesigning compliance materials using simplification, chunking, and increasing salience.
2. Enhancing training with both "fast thinking" approaches (using emotionally resonant examples) and "slow thinking" techniques (interactive tools like suitability calculators).
3. Improving suitability processes by applying choice architecture principles and using social proof to highlight compliant behaviors of high-performing producers.
4. Developing comprehension tests for producers to assess understanding and refine training approaches.
The article emphasizes the importance of addressing both System 1 (fast, intuitive) and System 2 (slow, deliberate) thinking in compliance materials and training. It suggests focusing on four key elements to improve comprehension: make it easy, make it timely, make it salient, and make it relevant.
As the insurance industry continues to evolve, particularly with the rise of direct-to-consumer sales channels, ensuring producer comprehension becomes even more critical. The principles outlined in the SOA study and interpreted through the lens of producer compliance offer a promising path forward for creating more effective, engaging training and support materials.
While this innovative approach shows great potential, the article stresses the importance of continually measuring its impact on producer behavior and refining strategies based on real-world results. As we move forward, the integration of behavioral science into compliance programs may well become a standard practice, leading to better outcomes for producers, consumers, and insurers alike.
This important research and its potential applications in compliance mark an exciting new chapter in the insurance industry's ongoing efforts to improve comprehension, compliance, and ultimately, customer outcomes.
For information subscriptions to Insurance Compliance Insight, contact admin@ins-compliance.com
↓ READ MORE ↓
